One of the scariest things for me is writing my own songs. This is where all my gremlins and negative inner voices pop up real fast.
You may know that my whole singing journey has been a journey through fear towards love. Have I shared that with you before? Probably here and there. While singing was a needed and dependable comfort to me as a child, the act of singing in front of other people in anything resembling a performance setting was so scary that it completely put me off a life centered around singing, which was always the life I wanted. So, that’s a big deal.
Incrementally, and much to my delight, I found ways to identify both how important singing and making music is to me, and how to start to remedy the situation.
So here I am, singing up a storm most days – woohoo! I love my job, I love my life and I love the songs I sing. And I love to improvise with my instruments and my voice, just making stuff up on the spot. (I even went through a 4-year program to learn how to be a music improv facilitator with the awesome-est of organizations: Music for People.) I can express my feelings in the moment melodically and rhythmically, but I’ve been relatively stuck when it comes to words. Which if you know me may surprise you because I talk a lot. But it’s true.
I have a lot of anxiety about putting my own words to my own music — I think that’s called “song writing?” Eeeek.
I am so afraid of writing songs that suck. That are cliche. That are so un-cliche that they won’t make any sense to anybody. That are whiny and pathetic. Boring. Embarrassing. That even if it’s a good song, it will offend someone in my life. Blah blah blah, you name it. The inner critic goes wild!
But it’s like a holy grail, right? I’ve spent so much time singing other people’s great songs, that I’ve put great songs up on a high pedestal, and to create a song that’s not so great feels like some kind of crime. But is this not exactly what I rail against around singing in general?? That we don’t have to be perfect? That singing and using our voice is our birthright? You know it, baby!
So it’s time! And I thought I’d share this here with you.
I did write a few songs (2), about five years ago. It took me about 6 months before I tentatively shared the first one with a friend, and then with my husband, and then several years more before I shared it with my band. When we finally sang it out, it was very rewarding and fun. It was about my son, and he was in the audience and he teared up — it doesn’t really get better than that. I made the second one around that same time and though I like it, our band could never figure out an arrangement that worked for it — I think it needs some tweaking and for that I think I need more experience and to gather some skills. Which you only get by doing it.
So I got this book. How to Sing One Song by Jeff Tweedy, of the band Wilco.
It’s been liberating and joyful to hear what he has to say and to play with his suggestions and exercises. His way of thinking suits my ADD brain — pulling together loose associations and playfully assembling them to create a story through ambience, and to match it up with a tune. Jeff (who I only know through his book, but who I now feel is my good buddy) is a delightful and supportive mentor. Perfect for me.
I’m really having a blast and letting myself get obsessed. And letting myself sound whiny and pathetic or goofy or whatever — mainly not to worry so much about writing bad songs and just keep on going. It’s really about the practice of letting what’s inside get outside, and experiencing the joy of creating for it’s own sake. It makes me feel good.
This is my bold announcement: I’m writing songs. Boom. I said it.
So, what about you? What do you want to do?
What makes you feel good? Singing? Drawing? Dancing? Engineering? Fixing motorcycles? Helping other people? Whatever it is, give yourself permission! Why the hell not? We can get all tied up in knots and stop ourselves from doing stuff, but it’s so much more fun to just do it.
Cool! Can we hear one? 😉
What a great post! So inspiring. I have a friend that is a song writer. He doesn’t write words, just melodies and harmony. He has written over 400 songs in the last several years since he started. His goal is to try and write one song a week. Sometimes he writes more and sometimes he writes less, and sometimes a song sound similar to a previous one but he keeps writing. His theory is you have to build a habit, do it consistency, and write lots of songs for those little gems to pop out. He had read that Paul McCartney followed a similar technique. I believe you will write some great songs!
.
Besides my passion for music, playing guitar, and learning to sing, I’ve always had a passion for arts and crafts but like singing, never took the time to actually create anything due to my fear of being judged. Now, I couldn’t agree more with your statement – “Why the hell not?” So that is why recently I’ve started learning to draw and paint. And besides neither my wife or myself wearing jewelry, I’ve decided to learn metalsmith skills and jewelry design. I enjoy making things with my hands and like detail work. I have ideas in my head that need to come out, and that’s enough to start. Happy song writing!
Hi Mark — So glad you enjoyed the post!
Did you know that I made jewelry for a living for about 10 years? Made from paper mostly. Good for you guys — you’re definitely doing LOTS of stuff that you want to be doing!
And thanks for your encouragement!
Nancy
❤️
My goodness. This was like reading my own story. I’m a singer who struggled with performance for years, and even though I’ve sang through hundreds of four-hour shows and thousands of peer-pressured karaoke one-offs, I still am a ball of nerves if I’m in the spotlight.
Where it really got weird was when you started talking about how you can improvise melody and rhythm vocally with anyone, but the lyrics just won’t come because there’s always something screaming that it’s not right, it’s not good enough, it’s too straightforward, etc. I am a damn good prose writer, I can do this all day… But when it comes to putting words on any of the 50-ish songs I have fully recorded, just waiting for the vocals… I just… Can’t. What’s more, the self-hate that stems from that failure perpetuates a vicious cycle of doubt that leads to more doubt that leads to giving up. Time after time after time. I have no idea how to overcome it.
Hi Seth!
Somehow I missed your comment on my post before — I’m so sorry I never replied! It sounds like you understand my (former) plight all too well!
I had great success breaking through my songwriting barrier with the help of the book I mentioned in the post: How to Write One Song, by Jeff Tweedy. He had lots of suggestions and I landed on a little system for myself that kind of worked magic. It got me out of that cycle of judgement and into a really creative space.
I can’t tell you objectively if the songs I wrote were “good” or not (whatever that means) but I did write 14 songs in 4 months that I’ve actually been singing for and with other people. And I LOVED the process.
If you’d like to chat about this sometime feel free to use this link to set up a time to meet: https://calendly.com/event_types/user/me
Thanks for reaching out — and apologies for the long delay!
Warmly,
Nancy